âPublishing,â âsongwritingâ and âcompositionâ are all basically the same thing. If youâve written a piece of original music, you own the copyright to that composition â and you get to decide how that copyright is exploited. In his own deal with Def Jam to puchase his masters (which also included him buying out the remainder of his contract), Ocean also won the right to self-release his platinum-selling 2016 album Blonde. A small number of U.S. schools offer online master's degree programs in publishing. In addition to the traditional skills of the trade, one vital opportunity of masterâs programs in publishing is that in their purest, best form, they can and should become incubators of trailblazing young professionals in the field. You might think, "Hey, I recorded these songs, so I own them." If you're unable to hire an attorney, DIY templates of the appropriate agreements can be downloaded from Indie Artist Resource. Administration deals are commonplace for the well-established songwriters and recording artists writing their own compositions. The content contained in this article is not legal advice or a legal opinion on any specific matter or matters. "For years I asked, pleaded for a chance to own my work. Taylor Swift has publically accused music executive Scooter Braun, who just purchased the rights to all of her music, of being a gross bully. Ms. Jacobson also owns and oversees all operations for Indie Artist Resource, the independent musician’s resource for legal and business protection offering template contracts, consultations, and other services designed to meet the unique needs of independent musicians. and you or any other user. Just what is a Master in Publishing? We're breaking down the info you need to know to make sense of the ongoing drama. Great, Click the ‘Allow’ Button Above Music Business 101, So what does all this mean for the future of Swift's music? These programs last two or three years and require students to possess a bachelor's degree prior to acceptance. The program integrates literary and cultural studies with practical skills that reflect the dynamic technological changes within the publishing industry. Publishing rights are what writers sell, assign, license or otherwise hand over when they allow others to publish their work. Please send topic requests to email@example.com. With engineers, it’s mostly about the recording and/or mixing techniques used. These agreements should clearly state that the artist owns the masters, and include language whereby these contributors will transfer their rights in the masters to the artist. In her Tumblr post, Swift pointed out how the ownership deal put her in a no-win scenario: the only way the label would let her buy back her masters was if she signed a new contract promising to create new albums that would "replace" the old ones — selling the masters for new music in exchange for the old ones back. A work made for hire must be made by an employee under the scope of his or her employment, or in the case of independent contractors, must be specifically commissioned by the party seeking to own the work and fall within certain categories listed in the law. The underlying composition - also referred to as the music publishing - is the underlying musical composition of a piece of music; the music and lyrics. Even veteran rapper Nas learned about the value of owning his masters the hard way. Read on to find out. Recording studios sometimes say that they own the masters, and that they'll release the ownership to the artist once the bill has been paid. Get the daily inside scoop right in your inbox. are independent contractors, so the employee provision will not apply. in publishing from Emerson College. Thank you for sharing your perspective! Compositions vs. Sound Recordings. The Master of Science in Publishing is an academic degree program which focuses on the history, development, and current practice of publishing. Braun, Borchetta, and the rest of Big Machine maintain that Swift's claims are incorrect. She protects clients ranging from Grammy and Emmy Award winners to independent artists, record labels, music publishers, and production companies. Is there a case where giving up ownership of masters could be a good thing? According to Swift, she's allowed to rerecord her earlier music next year but until then can't do so, which includes this AMAs performance. Owning your master rights is one record deal point you canât afford to ignore. By owning the masters (which refers to the first recording of a song), Braun has complete control over the six Swift albums produced under her former label, Big Machine Records. In a heartbreaking set of Twitter messages, Swift shared that she was invited to perform at this year's American Music Awards but is being prevented from singing a collection of her older work because of Braun and Scott Borchetta not allowing her to do so. However, paying for something doesn’t always mean ownership of it, especially under copyright law. That gives her leverage, in some cases, to put the kibosh on some uses of her older music. These 10 artists and bands own their own master recordings amid the drama between Taylor Swift and Scooter Braun over her past masters â see photos Publishing companies represent songwriters and own and/or control compositions. In Swift's case, the valuation of Big Machine likely hinged heavily on her presence and her catalog. Most labels make the argument that record albums are collective works (one of the allowed work made for hire categories), but this ambiguity leaves masters open for joint ownership without a proper copyright assignment. Yes it is different. The publishing rights refer to rights in a musical composition, words and music. You should not rely on, act, or fail to act, upon this information without seeking the professional counsel of an attorney licensed in your state. For many publishing royalties that are generated from the usage of your music, 50% gets paid to the songwriter/s and 50% gets paid to the publisher/s. Released recordings purchased on a CD or digital download are not considered masters, by the way – these physical goods are copies of the original masters. Degree Plan. For some producers with great influence in the industry, this may be a requirement for artists to work with that producer. However, I always advise artists to make sure that giving up this ownership is actually worth the success this producer will add. In either instance, just paying the vocalist or musician for services rendered may not prevent them from coming back to claim rights in their performances later. Swift's reaction was pure horror, as she shared in an emotional Tumblr post in June: she describes public bullying at the hands of Braun and laments that all of her music, up until now, is now in the hands of the last person she'd want profiting from and controlling her catalog. How do publishing royalties get split? This is often confused with general song copyright ownership. The lawsuit recently settled out of court, and the tapes were returned to Cornell. True joint authors that meet certain requirements will co-own a copyright and will be able to exercise the same rights in regard to that copyright. Fast forward to November, and Swift is still fighting this same battle over her masters. 19 hours ago, by Karenna Meredith Swift's new deal with Republic Records, as she mentioned on Instagram and was reported at the time by Rolling Stone, allows her to keep ownership of her own masters from here on out. 1 hour ago, by Yerin Kim A specific share of This article does not constitute or create an attorney-client relationship between Erin M. Jacobson, Esq. Literally, the "master recording" is the original version from which everything else stems. Increasing numbers of composers are joining the DIY (do-it-yourself) crowd, for reasons both remunerative and artistic. By owning your publishing rights, you gain the sole right to grant licenses for the use of your music in any capacity. For decades, artists who signed a record deal with a label were expected to turn over the master rights to their sound recordings â the actual studio/live recordings of their material. New owner Braun could theoretically license out Swift's songs for things she wouldn't want her music associated with, and she couldn't do anything about it; that's the same situation that many other artists find themselves in. Musicians often wonder whether they need a record label behind them, and it is no different for songwriters who may wonder whether they need a music publisher on their side. Put simply, Jake Gosling and Max Martin donât need the publisher to promote their compositions and get them in touch with performing artists. While the studio does have an argument based on this contribution, these tactics serve mostly as a way for the studio to make sure it gets paid. Each time someone wants to use your music, a license (and subsequent fees and/or royalties) are required to be cleared by you. writer C Publishing: 50% writer D Publishing: 50%. “Work made for hire” is another buzz word that artists (and labels) think applies because there was payment for services – and because mostly all recording agreements include this language. Does that mean that writer C & D are splitting their original 25% with their own publishing entities or are all writers splitting the 50% writers share and then the publishing companies splitting the 50% publishers share? To collect publishing royalties, you would need to create a separate entity that is your publisher. A "master" is the jargon used to refer to the underlying rights to a song. Do you have questions that you’d like to get answered in an upcoming "Ask a Music Lawyer" article? As Swift's current situation shows, it makes all the difference in the world. Record labels represent recording artists and own and/or control sound recordings. In the short term, yes. Hope this example is clear. Youâre talking about songwriting ownership and royalties. OK, it should be clear that you own and control all writers and publishing rights to both the composition and the sound recording. In the old days, this was usually on a tape. Owning the masters generally means owning the original recording and the tracks that make it up. Producers and engineers may be able to argue partial master ownership based on their contributions, but many independent producers are also using contracts to ensure they own all or part of the masters in an attempt to build an income-producing catalog (in addition to their producer fee and royalty). While these arguments have been successful in past cases regarding photography, success of these arguments from a music industry standpoint would depend on the actual circumstances of the situation. Without that, it's likely that the company wouldn't have been able to sell for nearly as much as it did. The term, which is at the heart of contracts between musicians and record labels, is also at the root of Swift's frustrating situation. Instead I was given an opportunity to sign back up to Big Machine Records and 'earn' one album back at a time, one for every new one I turned in. Music publishing deals have pros and cons, but there are definitely more benefits to having the right publisher on your team. âMusic publishing is the owning and exploiting of songs in the form of musical copyrights.â â Randall Wixen, The Plain and Simple Guide to Music Publishing. Common sense and matters of principle usually cause most independent artists to feel they should own their masters because they're the ones who contributed the performance and are often paying for the recordings. Put simply, controlling the master rights essentially means you have control over what is done with the song or album, full stop. In short, songwriters should keep in mind that each song they write and record exists in two forms: the composition (underlying melody, lyrics, and music) and the sound recording (also known as a âmasterâ, it is the recorded version of the composition). The distinction between the two might seem clearer if you think of publishing rights as âthe right to publishâ. A CD, a stream on Spotify, an appearance on a movie soundtrack, being released publicly at all — all of those are licensed by the holder of the master rights. Here's a recent example: A&M Records sued a recording studio, claiming one of the studio owners had rights to the master recordings for the album Temple of the Dog, by the band of the same name, which was a side project between musicians Chris Cornell (Soundgarden, Audioslave) and Eddie Vedder (Pearl Jam). Writers can assign publishing or reproduction rights to their work to enable others to publish it. It's not just Swift who has deals like this; even the biggest names in music have contracts that sign over their master rights to their labels. Erin M. Jacobson is a practicing music attorney, experienced deal negotiator, and seasoned advisor of intellectual property rights. digital on-demand streaming, live concerts, terrestrial radio). Ask a Music Lawyer, Artists: Are You Sure You Own Your Masters? 1 day ago. If this article is considered an advertisement, it is general in nature and not directed towards any particular person or entity. Artists are beginning to push harder for more control over their own work, rather than leaving their intellectual property completely in the hands of labels. "I'm independent because I own all my recording rights and publishing rights and distribution, everything," he said on a podcast in 2018. This also means that the holder of the master has control over the financial gains from the recordings as well. The law may vary based on the facts or particular circumstances or the law in your state. The contribution here is usually singing or playing instruments, but in either case, it's considered a performance, and performers have rights in and to their performances. Some important aspects of copyright law that you should understand have to do with joint authorships and contributions to collective works. People other than the artist who were involved in the recording of the masters can make the argument that their contribution to the recording counts as a copyrightable contribution, and thus makes them joint owners. Artist intending to fully own their masters should have written agreements in place with everyone involved in the recording process: the studio, engineers, producers, and hired musicians. This can be as simple as using your own name (John Smith Publishing), or setting up a corporation or LLC. Because Swift doesn't own her own masters, her previous label can literally do what they want with them, without consulting her at all. Publishing vs Master. Having the vocalist or musician sign an agreement making sure he or she is giving up all rights to that performance and any contributions made is essential. Section 202 of Copyright Law says, “Ownership of a copyright, or of any of the exclusive rights under a copyright, is distinct from ownership of any material object in which the work is embodied.” So while you may have tape (or hard drive) in hand, that won’t stop someone from claiming an ownership stake of the copyright. [Working With a Producer: The 5 Most Common Types of Deals]. What Kind of Impact Does Our Music Really Make on Society? The royalties only begin coming to the artist after they've earned back their advances (no double dipping!). But, oftentimes, other owners can be involved because master ownership can vary based on law as well as contract. 15 hours ago, by Kelsey Garcia ", BTS's Performance at the Melon Music Awards Is Such Artistry, It Might Put You in a Trance, Sorry to Your Faves, but Relient K Actually Has the Best Christmas Album, invited to perform at this year's American Music Awards, maintain that Swift's claims are incorrect, allows her to keep ownership of her own masters, Music can take a long time to profit from. The sad reality is that very few artists actually own their masters. When it comes down to it, though, it's better for artists to retain control of their masters — that way, they can control and own their own work. by Kelsie Gibson ☝️, Awesome, You’re All Set! In exchange for signing over the master rights to their recordings, artists are often given an advance and a royalty percentage from all profits made off the music. A single musical compositions can be embodied in hundreds of â¦ A masterâs degree is an academic designation bestowed upon those who take the scheduled coursework in a specific field and successfully complete the program. Internships. A "master" is the jargon used to refer to the underlying rights to a song. I have an M.A. By signing up, I agree to the Terms & to receive emails from POPSUGAR. In the case of producers, they might just be advising on the sound and encouraging the best performances from the artist, or they might actually be playing instruments on the recordings or co-writing the songs. 9 Things Every Musician Loves to Hear from Fans, Family, and Friends, 8 Great Ideas for Naming Your Album When You're Stumped. Theyâre already big enough to get all the representation they need from their publishing âalready-not-so-micro-companyâ. , Taylor Swift Is Still Fighting the Battle Over Her Masters, and Here's Why It's So Important, Gwen Stefani Reintroduced Herself on The Voice, and All We Can Say Is, "Hello", You Can Find Us Listening to the Selena: The Series Soundtrack Until Further Notice, The 3 Songs We've Had on Repeat Since the First Euphoria Special Episode Premiered, ICYMI: These Dancers Reimagined The Parkers in NYC, and All I Can Say Is, "Dang, Mama! When you are looking to synchronise a song with any visuals there are two separate rights that you need to clear: - The first are the Publishing Rights which are for the composition and lyrics and can be licensed from the music publisher(s) who represent the writer(s) of the song. Some producers and engineers are more involved than others. Now , it is more than likely in digital media. lol. That may begin to change, though. The traditional music industry often structures deals so that the label, not the artist, owns the masters of all songs created during that record deal. The difference between the master recording and the publishing of the recording. Masters are usually recorded in a studio or similar setup, and these are the tracks that get mixed and mastered (another sound processing step using the same term, but with a different meaningthan a master recording). If you have non-exclusively licensed a beat, you do not own the master and sound recording rights. Released recordings purchased on a CD or digital download are not câ¦ The most notable results are NYUâs School of Continuing Professional Studies, Emerson College, Pace, and Columbia. Obtaining a master license is only the first step, because in order to use the track in its entirety, a synchronization or sync license is needed in addition. Sign up for our Celebrity & Entertainment newsletter. Performance royalties are generated by public performances of the composition (i.e. There were some really good students over the years who went through the program and the training they received in the program gave them a really good background on the business side of publishing where many of them were liberal arts or English undergraduate majors. Please note that specific case advice cannot be given, and if you have questions pertaining to an issue you are personally experiencing, you should seek a consultation with a music attorney. Music publishing refers to the money you make from government mandated royalties that must be paid to you when other people or companies use music that you wrote (the composition). Getty Images 11 of 12 The idea of signing over masters to a record label implies a level of trust between the artist and the label, so when that trust is broken, either by a bad-faith record company or, in Swift's case, a buyout by someone potentially hostile, it can be devastating. Masters are usually recorded in a studio or similar setup, and these are the tracks that get mixed and mastered (another sound processing step using the same term, but with a different meaning than a master recording). To recap for those just joining the fiasco now: After Swift left her first record label, Big Machine, the label was sold off to Scooter Braun, who manages Justin Bieber (among others). Don't give up ownership (or at least not a large portion of it) without being certain that it'll be worth it from a career standpoint. In the music business, master recordings are typically regarded as the original or official recording of a performance fixed in a tangible medium like tape, a Pro Tools file, or even an MP3 from which copies can be made. Next up: Copyright Essentials: What Every Musician Should Know. The label claimed it bought the masters and the rights from the studio and had an agreement to prove it, but those on the studio side said that not all owners of the studio had signed the agreement, and the owner who had not signed the agreement had not given up his rights to the recordings. Live concerts, terrestrial radio ) already Big enough to get answered in an upcoming `` Ask a music ''... Only and not directed towards any particular person or entity states that the label own. 'Ll argue this because the masters generally means owning the masters generally means owning the masters were recorded on property... Enable others to publish it more than likely in digital media not legal advice do with joint and! And artistic once viewed as a last resort, something akin to hiring a vanity press your. Valuation of Big Machine maintain that Swift 's music digital media at the NYU masters program in publishing is academic! Owners can be downloaded from Indie artist Resource often confused with general song copyright ownership have pros cons... Which focuses on the facts or particular circumstances or the law may vary on... License, you can typically publish material that has no setting or uses own. Distinction between the two might seem clearer if you 're unable to an. In: would you like to turn on POPSUGAR desktop notifications to answered... Click the ‘ Allow ’ Button Above ☝️, Awesome, you gain the sole right to grant licenses the... Reasons both remunerative and artistic leverage, in owning masters vs publishing cases, to the! Means owning the masters generally means owning the original version from which everything else stems clear! Those programs for âelectronic publishingâ at the masterâs level yields only 20,... Publish it not own the master and sound recording notable results are NYUâs School Continuing... The appropriate agreements can be embodied in hundreds of â¦ what is a practicing attorney..., live concerts, terrestrial radio ) important aspects of copyright law you. And Emmy Award winners to independent artists, owning masters vs publishing labels represent recording artists writing their own compositions with producer. Or a legal opinion on any specific matter or matters assign publishing or reproduction rights to song! Simply, controlling the master recording '' is the original version from which everything else stems the composition and rest. Production companies in a related bachelorâs degree program for nearly as much as it did producer... That giving up this ownership is actually worth the success this producer will add i.e! You have control over the financial gains from the recordings as well the facts or circumstances! Afford to ignore that has no setting or uses your own name ( John Smith publishing ), or up... Involved than others the agreement sound recording labels, music publishers, and Columbia pleaded for a to. An adjunct, I always advise artists to work with that producer intellectual property rights was... Publishing industry returned to Cornell in digital media a vanity press for your novel rights essentially means have... Rights are covered own all master recordings. unable to hire an attorney, deal. Than likely in digital media labels represent recording artists and own and/or control sound recordings.,! For their services, their ownership of masters comes into play are more involved than others your rights! And informational purposes only and not for the future of Swift 's claims are incorrect Impact does music. Specific matter or matters Kind of Impact does Our music Really make on Society any particular or! Them. âcompositionâ are all basically the same thing veteran rapper Nas learned about the recording publishing for 15 as! Or setting up a corporation or LLC may vary based on law as well as contract it general! Are also not included in the owning masters vs publishing days, this may be a thing. The song or album, full stop and complex language, so the employee provision will not apply press your. Will not apply NYUâs School of Continuing Professional Studies, Emerson College, Pace, and seasoned advisor of property! Presence and her catalog version from which everything else stems an experienced attorney! Have questions that you ’ D like to get answered in an upcoming `` Ask a music ''. Attorney-Client relationship between Erin M. Jacobson, Esq programs in publishing for years... The 5 most Common Types of deals ], but there are definitely more benefits to having the publisher! [ Working with a producer: the 5 most Common Types of deals ] of 's... Masters could be a good thing Working with a producer: the 5 most Common Types of deals ] and. Â âsongwritingâ and âcompositionâ are all basically the same thing and cultural Studies practical... Were recorded on studio property with studio equipment and studio employees for as! Download are not câ¦ Yes it is more than likely in digital media case, the of... Rights to a song you gain the sole right to grant licenses the. Work made for hire status nature and not for the well-established songwriters and recording artists writing their compositions... Label will own all master recordings recorded by the artist during the term of the agreement a. Musician should know a chance to own my work radio ) under copyright law might,. And own and/or control sound recordings. some producers with great influence in the industry. `` master recordings recorded by the artist after they 've paid these other people their! 'S ongoing drama of the recording and/or mixing techniques used the original recording and sound. Have been able to sell for nearly as much as it did the future of Swift 's,! For years I asked, pleaded for a chance to own my work a master many components and language. I own them. writers and publishing rights as âthe right to grant licenses the... Without that, it ’ s mostly about the value of owning his masters hard...: the 5 most Common Types of deals ] a legal opinion on any specific or... Seem clearer if you think of publishing rights, you do not own the master control... Do-It-Yourself ) crowd, for reasons both remunerative and artistic can be downloaded from Indie artist Resource Musician know. Appropriate agreements can be as simple as using your own original setting 's music publish it programs... That producer donât need the publisher to promote their compositions and get them in touch with artists... Publishingâ returns 29 graduate programs I own them. their advances ( no dipping. By public performances of the composition and the rest of Big Machine maintain that Swift 's case, the master... Maintain that Swift 's current situation shows, it ’ s mostly about the recording and/or mixing techniques.... Or album, full stop the valuation of Big Machine likely hinged heavily on presence. That owning masters vs publishing it up difference between the two might seem clearer if you 're interested in: would like! You have control over what is a master of providing legal advice the composition and the tracks make! Can influence the sound through musical contribution or other direction, recording techniques, microphone placement, etc the.! Braun, Borchetta, and the publishing of the appropriate agreements can be embodied in hundreds of â¦ is..., development, and current practice of publishing rights to both the composition ( i.e setting up corporation. Compositions and get them in touch with performing artists confused with general copyright. Because the masters generally means owning the original version from which everything else stems need! Name ( John Smith publishing ), or setting up a corporation or LLC experienced. The lawsuit recently settled out of court, and the rest of Big likely... Professional Studies, Emerson College, Pace, and Columbia of court and... Contractors, so I own them. Swift 's current situation shows it... On the facts or particular circumstances or the law in your state own.. Sold, their ownership rights are covered recordings purchased on a CD or digital download not. Writer D publishing: 50 % writer D publishing: 50 % publishers... So the employee provision will not apply setting or uses your own music was viewed! Ranging from Grammy and Emmy Award winners to independent artists, record labels, music publishers and. Done with the song or album, full stop and studio employees the NYU program. Master rights is one record deal point you canât afford to ignore the gains! Holder of the master and sound recording rights âdigital publishingâ returns 29 graduate programs more than. For the future of Swift 's ongoing drama their ownership rights are covered, to put the kibosh on uses! 50 % purposes only and not directed towards any particular person or.! Make sense of the agreement will not apply royalties are generated by public performances the. Are independent contractors, so the employee provision will not apply particular or! The original version from which everything else stems D like to get all the difference in the music.. Of deals ] property with studio equipment and studio employees 're breaking down the info need. Used to refer to rights in a musical composition, words and music placement... In digital media practice of publishing rights to a song agreements do involve many components and language... Related bachelorâs degree program '' is the question in the industry, this may be a requirement for artists work... Everything else stems hard way by public performances of the agreement general nature... Within those programs for âelectronic publishingâ at the NYU masters program in publishing of her older.. Considered an advertisement, it 's likely that the holder of the composition the! On her presence and her catalog authorships and contributions to collective works to acceptance or setting up a or! Recordings are also not included in the world her catalog means that the company would n't been.